Phones answered 24/7Springfield, MA
Call (833) 490-5225
Phones answered 24/7Call any time(833) 490-5225
Guide

Storm water, sewer backup or a plumbing leak: which one is it?

Storm water, sewer backup and a leaking pipe look alike in a Springfield cellar. How to tell them apart before you call, and what the city's sewers mean.

Illustration for the guide "Storm water, sewer backup or a plumbing leak: which one is it?" (Springfield, MA)
Short answer

Water in a Springfield basement can come from three places: rain and runoff entering through the foundation, sewage backing up from the street through a floor drain, or a leak in the house's own pipes. Each is handled differently, so the first question is always the source.

Key takeaways

  • Springfield's combined sewers carry storm runoff and wastewater in one system, mostly under its older neighborhoods.
  • Storm water usually comes in from outside and falls as the rain stops, while a backup rises through drains and keeps coming.
  • A pipe or appliance leak has one clear source point and stops when the fixture is turned off.
  • Sewage and storm water that has crossed soil are contaminated, and the crew records that category before drying.
  • Write down the timing and the location before you call, because the first questions are about exactly those things.
  • Ask whether a backflow valve or a sump would reduce the risk, once the cellar is dry.

Why does the city's sewer system matter for a basement?

Much of Springfield is served by combined sewers, which carry storm runoff and wastewater in the same pipe. Those systems lie mostly under the older neighborhoods, and the pipes overflow when heavy rain pushes more water through them than they can carry.

The Springfield Water and Sewer Commission and the EPA's profile of the city describe roughly 150 miles of combined sewer pipe, mostly in the older neighborhoods. The system has 24 combined sewer outfalls, which discharge to the Connecticut, Chicopee and Mill rivers when heavy rain exceeds what the pipes can carry.

The commission's own explanation is that the overflows keep water out of basements. That is the purpose of the design, and it is not a guarantee for any single house on any given night, so a cellar can still take water during a storm.

This guide does not claim that overflows cause basement backups on any particular street. No such report was found for a named street, so the source of your water is for the crew and your own records to establish, not a map.

What does storm water in a basement look like?

Storm water usually enters through foundation cracks, window wells, bulkhead doors and walls with poor grading outside. It rises from the floor or runs in from one side, and its level tends to follow the outside rain.

Look for water along the foundation walls first, especially in the corners, and for a damp line on the floor that follows the wall. If the water appeared during a storm and went down afterward, it most likely came in from outside.

Storm water often leaves a line on the wall and a layer of silt. Silt on the floor and a damp, musty smell show the water has been in contact with soil and surface runoff, so it should be handled with the same care as river water.

Storm water is most common in cellars with poor drainage outside or cracked walls. A walk around the outside after the rain, looking at gutters, downspouts and the grade beside the foundation, often explains the water before anyone goes inside.

What does a sewer backup look like?

Sewer backup comes up through floor drains, toilets, laundry tubs and sometimes the lowest shower. It carries an unmistakable odor and usually solids, and it must always be treated as sewage.

When the street sewer is full, wastewater can rise through the lowest drains in the house. If you see water coming up through a floor drain while the toilets or sinks upstairs are running slowly, the source is probably on the sewer side.

Sewage changes the cleanup. Porous materials that sewage has touched, including carpet, pad, drywall and insulation, are usually removed rather than dried, and the crew records the water category before any work is approved.

Do not flush toilets or run water while sewage is backing up. Keep children and pets out of the area, and wash hands and any exposed skin after contact. A plumber can check whether a backflow valve is present and working, which is a good question to ask once the cleanup is done.

How do you tell a pipe leak from both?

A leak from a pipe or an appliance usually has one source point, starts when the fixture is used or a pipe freezes, and does not rise from a drain. Water from a leak is often clean at the source, though it can pick up contamination from the floor it crossed.

Check the water heater, the washing machine hoses, the toilet supply line and the pipes under each sink. A leak tends to wet one wall or one corner and to get worse when the appliance runs. A failed water heater often leaves a pool under the tank in the cellar.

Turn off the supply to the suspect fixture and watch whether the water stops. If it keeps rising after every fixture is off, the source is probably outside, through the foundation or a drain line, and it is more likely storm water or sewer.

Keep the test simple. Shut the main only if you can do so safely, and do not take anything apart before the area is photographed. The crew uses the same clues, and a clean record makes the source easier to confirm.

Which water ends up as contamination in a cellar?

Storm water that has crossed soil and sewage from a backed-up drain are both contaminated. Clean supply water becomes contaminated the moment it crosses a dirty surface, so the category depends on where the water has been as well as where it came from.

A basement that held storm water for a while picks up silt, soil and whatever was stored on the floor. Paint cans, garden products and other stored chemicals can leak into the water and must be kept away from skin.

Floor drains and sumps deserve the most caution. Water that has risen through them has been in the drain system, which can carry sewage even when the rain was the trigger that brought the water up.

Photograph stored items and move them up and out of the water if it is safe. Anything porous that has been in the water should be assumed unsafe until the crew says otherwise.

What is the right order of questions when water appears?

Ask where the water is, whether it is still rising, whether the rain has stopped, whether drains are backing up and whether any fixture is running. The answers point to the source far more reliably than a guess from the smell or the color.

Start with timing. Water that rose during the storm and is falling now points outward. Water that keeps rising after the rain has stopped suggests a drain or sump problem, and water that appears only while a fixture runs points to a pipe.

Then look at the drains without pouring anything into them. A floor drain that bubbles or pushes water up when an upstairs toilet flushes is showing you the sewer side of the house.

Write the answers down before you call. A short list of when, where and what you saw gives the call-taker, and then the crew, a clean starting point that saves time on the first visit.

What should you do once the water is out?

Once the water is out, dry the cellar, check the foundation and the drains, and ask whether a backflow valve or a sump would reduce the risk next time. Keep the records of the source and the cleanup together.

Drying a cellar takes equipment and patience. Keep the air moving, check the bottom of the walls for moisture, and avoid closing the room before readings show the materials are dry. A dehumidifier helps most once the water is gone and the room is closed up.

Ask a plumber about backflow prevention and the condition of the pipe between the house and the street. The commission is the right place to ask about the public sewer, and a plumber is the right person for the house side of the connection.

Keep the photographs, the readings and the crew's source notes together. If the source was sewer, ask the crew to record it that way, because the category shapes what can be kept and what has to go.

How do you talk to a crew about the source?

The crew will ask the same questions you asked yourself, so have the answers ready. The source they record decides the water category, the materials and the steps, and a few minutes spent describing it accurately saves time on the first visit.

Describe the timing in plain terms: when you first saw water, whether the rain was still falling, whether a nearby street drain or manhole was overflowing, and whether any fixture was running. Each detail narrows the possible sources and sends the crew to the right place sooner.

Show the crew the floor drains, the sump if there is one, the water heater and the washing machine connection. Let them check each one rather than telling them what you already think it is, because a confident guess that turns out wrong can slow the whole job down.

Ask the crew to write the source into the record in their own words, and check that the wording matches what you saw. If they cannot tell which it was, ask them to say so and to list what would confirm it, so the open question is on paper.

Frequently asked questions

Is it my fault if my basement floods in a storm?

Not necessarily. Storm and sewer water can enter a basement that is well kept, especially during heavy rain. The question for a claim is the cause, and the insurer decides under the policy.

Should I call the city about the sewer?

The Springfield Water and Sewer Commission handles questions about the public sewer system and its overflows. A crew handles the water inside the house. If you are unsure which side the water came from, say so when you call and ask for the source to be checked.

Can I run a sump pump during a backup?

A sump pump keeps water down only if it is working and its discharge is not feeding back into the house. If the water is coming up through a drain, a pump will not fix the source.

Does a floor drain always mean sewer?

Not always. A floor drain can also take in runoff or groundwater. The sign that points to sewer is water rising through the drain while fixtures upstairs are running or while the street sewers are full from the storm.

What should I do about mold after a basement flood?

Start drying quickly and keep the room open until the readings show dry. Old cellars with damp air are a common place for mold to start, and a crew can explain how drying and removal are scoped for your house.

This guide is general information for Hampden County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

One call and it gets handled.

A crew is dispatched as fast as one is available, and you approve the estimate before any work starts.

Keep reading

More guides

What moves a water damage quote in Springfield

A Springfield cleanup quote follows the rooms that stayed wet, the source of the water, the age and build of the house, and which materials can be dried in place rather than removed.

WhatsApp