Why does melt water back up under the shingles?
Snow on the roof melts from the heat that leaks from the house, and the water runs down to the eave where the roof is colder. When that water freezes at the edge, it blocks the next melt and the water has nowhere to go but under the roofing.
Shingles are designed to shed water that runs down them, not water that is pushed back up the slope. A dam makes the water pool, and the pooled water can work its way under the shingles and along the nail lines. A roof that is otherwise sound can still leak in this way.
The same heat that melts the snow also warms the attic, which is why the cycle is tied to the insulation and the ventilation. When the attic is warm and the eave is cold, the melt and refreeze repeat, and the dam grows with each storm.
How can a homeowner spot an ice dam before it leaks?
Look for a ridge of ice along the eave, icicles in a line on the gutter and snow that melts off the middle of the roof while the edge stays covered. Those signs show the cycle is running.
A roof that melts in a stripe across the middle while the edge stays white is usually losing heat from the attic. Watching for that pattern after a snowfall gives a homeowner a warning before the ceiling shows a stain.
Checking the attic on a cold morning is also useful. Frost on the roof boards, wet insulation near the eave or a warm spot beneath the hatch suggests the attic is losing heat and the eave may freeze. A visit before the next storm limits the damage more than a visit after it.
Should I remove the ice from the roof myself?
Clearing ice from a roof is risky, and a homeowner should not climb onto an icy surface or hack at the dam with a tool that can damage the shingles. Roof rakes from the ground can reduce snow load, but they are not a repair.
A ladder on snow or ice is one of the most common causes of serious falls in winter. A roofer with fall protection can clear the eave safely and check for damage to the shingles and flashing, and a homeowner should wait for that help rather than attempt it alone.
Mechanical removal can also loosen shingles, tear the drip edge or push water further under the roofing. Heat cables or a roofer's plan for ventilation are longer-term fixes, and the drying work inside the house has to start regardless of what is done on the roof.
What decides how far the water goes into a house?
The slope of the roof, the amount of insulation, the state of the flashing and how long the dam stays in place all decide how far the water travels. Each of those factors changes the drying plan.
A dam that sits for a long time over a single eave can soak a large part of the roof edge. Water that enters at a valley or a step in the roofline tends to reach a wall cavity more quickly, because the flashing is more complicated there and the water finds gaps.
The attic layout matters as well. An open attic with a few rafters is easier to dry than a finished attic with a knee wall, a closet and a sloped ceiling, because the finished spaces hold water in cavities that cannot be seen from the room.
Will the drying be finished once the ice melts?
No. The ice melting does not dry the insulation, sheathing or wall cavity, and the moisture can stay in the framing for weeks. Drying continues until readings show each material has reached its dry target.
Cold weather can slow drying, but the readings still decide when the work is complete. A technician returns after the first drying cycle to check the framing and the top plate, and the crew repeats the measurements until nothing is still holding water.
Once the readings settle, the wet insulation that was removed is replaced and the ceiling is closed up. A written record of the path, the materials and the readings goes to the homeowner and the roofer, so the next ice cycle can be compared with this one.